Thomas's Rant

Story, myth, writings

Posts Tagged ‘modernize religion

My 2008 book, The God Allusion, now online

with one comment

This is just a quick post to let you know that my 2008 book, The God Allusion, is now up on the website.
To check it out click on the image below.

God Allusion

Written by tomtomrant

7 May 2013 at 7:21 pm

Why Study Mythology? (3)

with 2 comments

I must admit that I didn’t mean to make these ‘Why Study Mythology?’ posts into a series but it seems this has happened as I have examined and re-examined a number of major interpretations. Whereas the 1st entry concerns a very general brainstorming, and the 2nd is modelled on the psychological theories of Jung and Joseph Campbell, this 3rd version is modelled on Jean-Paul Sartre’s phenomenology. It is, I think, more accurate but perhaps less clearer than the 2nd version.

Mythology is an imaginary construct discovered and created to provide a prism through which one views reality in a fulfilling and healthy way. The content of myth is imaginary and fantastic but the purpose is to effect an attitude rather than convey knowledge – factual or moral. This attitude amounts to an experience that can be likened to a flexible awareness of the possible structures and reaction patterns of humanity rather like knowing someone’s personality in that it gives one access to a general idea of behaviour with which one can relate and prosper.

This purpose is perverted in either of 2 ways:
(1) when the fantastic unreal quality of myth is taken as real and factual, the result is wrong history or narrow morality, (this is known as idolatry)
(2) when the elements of the myth are discontinuous with or alien to the present culture such that it is meaningless or nonsensical, the result is either rejection or, at best, a benign entertainment maintained for no true mythic reason (this is known as entertaining ‘false gods’). The myth fails to effect the appropriate attitude and remains out of synch with perceived reality.

It is probably only in very recent times that it has been necessary to recognize metaphoric and culture-specific expressions of myth. These two strains always appear together but in the past one could function without recognition of their separateness as humans existed mostly within defined cultural boundaries. This is no longer tenable in a global society and is highly destructive.

Written by tomtomrant

3 January 2013 at 10:50 pm

Posted in myth

Tagged with , ,

Why Study Mythology? (2)

leave a comment »

Mythology expresses universally powerful human reactions through culturally-specific forms thereby directing the power of these reactions into contemporary life. This brings organic emotional meaning to contemporary life and prevents these powers from becoming distracting or destructive.

It should be noted, however, that all religions worldwide are outdated; they now siphon powerful human reactions into culturally-outdated forms. This can be confusing and destructive, but we can still discover a modern mythological system by examining the commonalities between several religious systems.

These powerful human reactions can never be clearly expressed without a culturally-specific form – the forms are like material shells to incorporeal (and mysterious) meaning cores. The outdated shells can mislead but when compared across mythologies, we get the best approximation of the experience of these emotional cores, and in a manner that is informative for our own lives.

So ironically, the study of the commonalities of outdated religions can approximate a modern mythological system.

Can you live without it?

Of course you can, though you may wish to explore more fulfillment in life. And it helps to know the universal human meaning patterns so that if one day something happens to whatever it is you currently project meaning on, you won’t crack up quite so badly.  😛

Written by tomtomrant

20 June 2012 at 9:30 pm

Posted in myth

Tagged with , ,

Why Study Mythology?

leave a comment »

I’d love to teach Mythology. Someone asked me why people should study it. I realised I had no specific answer. Here is my answer (work in progress).

Mythology can be defined in many many different ways – it is regarded as wrong science, just fables, folk stories, attempts to explain the world, high art, a map of the psyche, social structuring schema, life guides, moral examples and much much more. Just about any one of these aspects is highly significant as it is and, I believe, more than justifies the study of myth in itself. Overall, mythologies are significant in that they reflect the unspoken mindset and perspective of the individual, the society and their relations to the world – plainly put, they are the most powerful and clear means of rendering “a sense of perspective”, the various levels of culture and thought and history within which we are positioned in this day and age. Mythologies properly do not so much comment on what the world is, or what things are – this is what our sciences are for – but mythologies reveal how we relate to the world, how we interrelate with each other, with other societies and with the universe. It is a study of the unspoken structures of value, meaning and feeling in society, on our own, at work, at play, in love, art, in action and rest – all life in time.

The “lessons” that mythology, properly studied, makes clear:

–       The difference between when something IS and when it is only AS IF something is. LITERAL thought versus ANALOGY. (Life as a game – the “as if” – not taken too seriously.)

–       Fear and desire (sex and power) are prevalent in life and that they are harmful if taken too seriously. Mythology exists to highlight forces more important for psychological well-being than these fear/desire forces, to develop an awareness of balancing these forces.

–       The mind posits an ELEMENTARY/MYSTIC IDEA and a PERSONAL/HISTORICAL IDEA of everything and that we should be aware of both and not mix up the two.

–       The difference between UNCONSCIOUS, COMPULSIVE, EMOTIONAL BEHAVIOUR/RELEASERS (sex, power, money, material possessions, love) and CONSCIOUS, VOLUNTARY, RATIONAL BEHAVIOUR/THINKING (logic, knowledge, number, goals, options).

–       The difference between the thing said and the WAY of saying it.

–       How an individual relates to society and how this in turn is shaped by history and the universe: specifically how ritual-forms (read: values/beliefs) of societies reflect their history and what is expected of the individual within these societies as a result of this. Examples:

  • the study would contrast different culture styles: nomadic hunter, versus foraging planter, versus agricultural town complex, versus high civilisation – on to globalised future = each social development is reflected in their myths.
  • the realisation that the modern city rests upon these ancient hints and ideas
  • Significantly, what this all means for our values, possibilities, and aspirations as reflected in how our societies choose to operate (what type of city-state we live in)
  • Evolving sex roles, individuality, attitudes regarding death
  • The focus of study is on how fictional stories (read: non-literal creative thinking) reflects society, individual and meaning, and how we unconsciously use such hypothetical myth-systems for our own and society’s ends.

–       The necessary universally unsolvable problems of life are discovered and outlined.

  • We must kill living things in order to live (primitive planters)
  • The important power of the parental elements: mother & father
  • The alluring power of the sexes: sublimating rather than repressing these
  • The stages that life prescribes from infancy, childhood, maturity, adulthood, to old age and death.
  • OVERALL: suggestions of the forces that humankind can change and those it may never have full access to.

–       Meaning is explored and its source found in ineffable numinous experience which is then extrapolated into local forms experienced on a daily basis

–       The difference between thinking in opposites (Aristotelian logic and science) and thinking in unities (compassion, feeling, meaning-systems).

  • the planter: mythological age versus the real one
  • the hunter: the shaman who acts as the interface between these two levels
  • Eastern city-state complex: the ever-turning cycles of time and the all-uniting Goddess
  • Western city-state complex: conquest and separation from the Goddess cycles and the maturing independent individual

–       The difference between God conceived as identity and as relationship..

Note there are 2 more posts in this series:
Why Study Mythology? (2)
Why Study Mythology? (3)

Written by tomtomrant

7 January 2012 at 12:40 pm

Posted in myth, philosophy

Tagged with ,

A Christmas Eucharist

with 2 comments

Pardon my impertinence, O Lord, as I rewriteth the Christmas Eucharist I all but slept through… (See the afterword for details.)


Silent night, holy night:

All is calm, all is bright

Round the virgin mother and child,

Holy infant so tender and mild,

Sleep in heavenly peace,

Sleep in heavenly peace.



Lay Minister: Today you may know that the Lord is born to bring new life and wonder.

Priest: In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.

All: Amen.

Priest: The Lord be with you.

All: And also with you.

Priest welcomes everyone.


(The four Advent candles have been lit already from subsequent Eucharists.)

Priest: God our Mystery, today the Christ is born and from darkness comes a great light. We have lit the candles of the left and the right, the north and south, the east and the west and we now light the tiny flame of Christ, the centre. As the tiny spark of new life, he is born out of the abyss of chaos, the star shining in the night – he is unexpected but, once born, seems always to have been known, anticipated, here with us always; Jesus Christ, the light, the generative power of the Spirit.

(The white Christmas candle is lit.)

All: Lord Jesus Christ, Light of Light,

You have come within us.

Help us feel and remember your light

To shine as light in our own lives.

Wonder to God in the highest.


Priest: Let us pray:

God our Mystery, on this day your Son Jesus Christ is born of the Virgin Mary for our wonder and enlightenment.

See here this crib and around it the ass and the ox – those great enemy brothers of Egypt, Set and Osiris, and yet they are gathered here in peace with the Christ child. And see also the three wise men of the god Mithra, come with treasures for the Christ child; the old principle deferring to the New Principle of Christ, born mysteriously of the Virgin in the lowly and unlooked for place.

For the stable is also a cave, as Christ is the new light shining in darkness. It is a cave and it is a womb of new and glorious beginnings beyond all imagination. It is the womb and it is the universe, darkness, denseness, chaos and fire then light! And energy! And expanding growth! It is the universe and the dark chamber of the human heart where the light of the divine is first engendered, beyond hope and unlooked for.

Proceed now, those who are able, into the darkness of the sanctum of Christ and behold the promise of the Holy Spirit.

(Those who are able proceed to the altar and crawl beneath it, emerging into the light before the Cross on the far side.)

Lay Minister: Jesus, the light of the world has come to dispel the darkness of our hearts. In his light let us recall our human imperfections and avow them to God the Mystery of All.

Pause for reflection (for at least 1 minute).

Lay Minister: The Virgin Mary accepts the call of God and is the mother of Jesus.

All: Accept and touch us also.

Lay Minister: Your Son the Christ accepts the call of God and is God himself.

All: Accept and touch us also.


All: Glory to God in the highest, and peace to all people. Lord God, King of Ourselves, we remind ourselves of your presence in all. Jesus Christ, Son of God, Lamb of God, you suffer from love: your magic is within us to call on the Father and the Holy Spirit of life. Amen.


Priest: Let us pray,

Eternal God, in the stillness of this night you sent your almighty Word to pierce the world’s darkness with the light of wonder: unlooked for he comes, a seed planted from the tree, hidden in leaf-litter unseen; the Christ child grows as but a green stem, then a shrub to grow upward to the Rood of the cross and, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, as one in God.

All: Amen.


GOSPEL (Matthew 2: 1-16)

Now after Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea in the days of Herod the king, behold, wise men from the east came to Jerusalem, saying, “Where is he who has been born king of the Jews? For we saw his star when it rose and have come to worship him.” When Herod the king heard this, he was troubled, and all Jerusalem with him; and assembling all the chief priests and scribes of the people, he inquired of them where the Christ was to be born. They told him, “In Bethlehem of Judea, for it is so written by the prophet…” Then Herod summoned the wise men secretly and ascertained from them what time the star had appeared. And he sent them to Bethlehem, saying, “Go and search diligently for the child, and when you have found him, bring me word, that I too may come and worship him.” After listening to the king, they went on their way. And behold, the star that they had seen when it rose went before them until it came to rest over the place where the child was. When they saw the star, they rejoiced exceedingly with great joy. And going into the house they saw the child with Mary his mother, and they fell down and worshiped him. Then, opening their treasures, they offered him gifts, gold and frankincense and myrrh. And being warned in a dream not to return to Herod, they departed to their own country by another way. Now when they had departed, behold, an angel of the Lord appeared to Joseph in a dream and said, “Rise, take the child and his mother, and flee to Egypt, and remain there until I tell you, for Herod is about to search for the child, to destroy him.” And he rose and took the child and his mother by night and departed to Egypt and remained there until the death of Herod. This was to fulfil what the Lord had spoken by the prophet, “Out of Egypt I called my son.” Then Herod, when he saw that he had been tricked by the wise men, became furious, and he sent and killed all the male children in Bethlehem and in all that region who were two years old or under, according to the time that he had ascertained from the wise men.

This is the Gospel of the Lord.

All: Praise to you, Lord Jesus Christ


Priest: Meister Eckhart said, “It is more worth to God his being brought forth ghostly in the individual virgin or good soul than that he was born of Mary bodily.” What did he mean? He is saying that the Virgin birth, I think, has nothing to do with biological wonders. We know from science that it is not possible to give birth as a virgin. Unless, that is, the message is not one of biological birth. “It is more worth to God his being brought forth ghostly in the individual virgin or good soul than that he was born of Mary bodily.” What can this mean? It is not a biological birth, it is a spiritual birth. Christ is born of the heart and if we ignore the call of Christ, then we become lost.

“Dread the Passage of Jesus, For He Will Not Return” was a line repeated by Monks in the middle ages. The cost is great in our lives when we do not acknowledge the compassion, the love, the passion of Christ; when we do not heed the call of our life goals, what our bodies and souls require of us. We become mechanical monsters, we become like King Herod, seeking to hold on to the ego, to the apparent power of self-interest and greed. And we commit the massacre of the innocents in miniature every day when we ignore our destinies, our feelings, give the world the cold shoulder and hide in the cave, trying vainly to extinguish the light that can inspire us. The children needn’t die for the Christ child; the Christ child will prosper all the same. When we hide from our fears, our inspirations and make no time to heed and develop the balance of the heart we massacre the children of our own lands, in our hearts. We batter ourselves upon the rocks, we strangle our own souls and their promise. The Christ needs only be acknowledged, like the shepherds did. We need only direct ourselves to his crib and stand to. He is born here in our hearts if we would but look for him.

“It is more worth to God his being brought forth ghostly in the individual virgin or good soul than that he was born of Mary bodily.”


All: We see the Mystery that is God. We feel the Mystery that is God. We are the Mystery that is God. I am the Mystery that is God.

We see the Lord Jesus Christ the Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father, God from God, Light from Light, of one being with the Father, through him all things are. In wonder he appears from within, is Incarnate of the Holy Spirit of God and the Virgin Mary, and becomes human in me. For all life he is crucified, suffers death, is buried and rises once more, at one with the Father. He it is who loves the living and the dead, his kingdom has no end.

We see the Holy Spirit, the giver of life, who proceeds from the Father and the Son and yet is the Father and the Son.

We see the holy Church of the soul. We acknowledge baptism for the inspiration of life. We carry the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world within.



Priest: We are the body of Christ.

All: His spirit is with us.

Priest: The peace of the Christ be always with you.

All: And also with you.

All may exchange the greet of peace, “Peace be with you,” among all of the people.


Priest: The Lord be with you.

All: And also with you.

Priest: Life up your hearts.

All: We lift them up to the Lord.

Priest: Let us give thanks to God.

All: Thanks to the mystery of God.

(All kneel.)

Priest: Lord God, through Christ accept our sacrifice of praise; and, by the power of your Word and Holy Spirit, sanctify this bread and wine, that we who share in this holy sacrament may be partakers of Christ’s body and blood and become one as He.

Christ, when his hour comes, the night before he goes up to the cross to unite with the glorious imperfections of the world, offers for all his sacrifice of himself, takes bread and gives you thanks; he breaks it and gives it to his disciples, saying:




In the same way, after supper, he takes the cup and gives you thanks; he gives it to us, saying,







Priest: Let us proclaim the mystery of life.

All: Christ is dead,

Christ is risen;

Christ comes again.

Priest: Through Christ grant that we who eat and drink these holy gifts may, by your Holy Spirit, be one body with Christ, to serve in unity and balance…

In your love and compassion, bring to us to realise eternal life. May we praise all in union, ourselves with ourselves through your Son Jesus Christ.

All: Blessing and honour and wonder be yours for all time. Amen.


The Priest introduces the Lord’s Prayer

All: Our Father in the heavens inside, hallowed be your name, your kingdom is here, your will is done, on earth as in heaven. Take we today our daily bread. Forgive us our sins as we forgive those who sin against us. Lead us to balance and deliver us from fear and desire.

Priest: We who are many are one body in Christ.

All: For all share in the one Bread.

The Priest then breaks the Bread during the Agnus Dei.

All: Lamb of God, you suffer from love: nourish all life.

Lamb of God, you suffer from love: nourish all life.

Lamb of God, you suffer from love: grant us peace.

The Priest then invites the people to Communion with the words:

Priest: This is the Lamb of God who suffers from love, who dies from love. Happy are those who are called to his supper.

All: We come to live on his life.

Those who are to receive Holy Communion or a blessing come forward.


Lay Minister: The Word of God becomes human; we see his glory.

Priest: Let us pray:

Father, the child born today is the Saviour of our world. He makes us your children. May he welcome us into your kingdom of eternal life.

All: Amen.

All: Father, we offer ourselves as a living sacrifice, as the Christ our Lord. Send us out in the power of your Spirit to live and work as Christs on earth. Amen.

Lay Minister: Go in the peace of Christ.

All: Thanks be to God.


So I returned to Christ Church Essendon for Christmas Eve’s carols and Eucharist. The ceremony was largely the same as last time (see earlier blog update under week 3) except this time it was dark outside (so the candles glowed all around), the weather was rather hot (so it got sticky and irksome), and I’d seen it all before. This time around the ritual was still correct but admittedly overlong and the concretized and backward historical nature of the text was really annoying me. It occurred to me that maybe the ideal transformation the Church requires is simply to fully adapt and explore the texts. As much as worship has changed in the schizophrenic splintering that has occurred since the Reformation, the essential words of the Bible itself have not changed. This is the biggest hurdle for the modern church. Modernising ye olde English is but a surface prettifier – the backward, extremism and historicizing is still radically out of step with our Western European sense of Self. I have attempted above to adapt the words of the Eucharist I attended on Christmas Eve into the sort of Eucharist I would love to hear and which means something to me. I have followed the order of proceedings all the way and there are in fact some sections where I was surprised to find very little change was necessary. The main points of change were the following:

1. Removal of sleep-inducing repetition. This nearly always occurred in passage of worship and adoration. “Holy and gracious God, all creation rightly gives you praise.” “It is indeed right… at all times and in all places to give you thanks and praise.” The mystery of God should definitely inspire submission and deference – the idea is of the conscious ego bowing down to the whole completeness of the Self – but to constantly carry on with worship for Jesus or the little boy laying down “his sweet head” in worship smacks of idolatry. Idolatry is getting caught on the material thing or personality; Jesus becomes a kind of supernatural superstar and the reference to ourselves, the mysterious light of inspiration, is lost. This occurs with any insistence upon history, personality cult or actual event. There is, in my opinion, too much of this in the Eucharist so I have trimmed some of this out (but suspect there might still be too much of it).

2. I attempted to selectively edit or reinterpret the Old Testament readings but I ended up with barely one line of them left. No point. The Old Testament, full of extremism and a vengeful God, does not belong in a modern Christian church – indeed the Christian God himself bears little resemblance to Yahweh or Elohim of the Old Testament. Read metaphorically, the images and stories may still have meaning, but the words in which they are described are so backward and the readings required are to be so stretched and contorted in order to avoid nonsense or worse that it is better and easier to have done with them altogether. (Inserting a reading from a Hindu or Zen Buddhist or American Indian text or indeed any other religion would be more enlightening and meaningful here.)

3. Finally, there are simple substitutions that can even be made ‘on the fly’ when reading texts in church. Convert any reference that refers to another time – that is, the past or the future – to now. For example, “For us he came down from heaven, was Incarnate of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary and became truly human,” becomes, “For us he comes down from heaven, is Incarnate of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary and becomes truly human.” Any references to “for ever” becomes “in eternity” (eternity being the opposite of time not actually a long period of time). Salvation and sin should be read as enlightenment and imbalance. References to another place, whether this is Israel, Nazareth or particularly heaven or hell, should refer to inside. (Generally the other world should be read as the inner world.) Heaven is not “up there” (space is up there) but is “within”.

Once again, my readings of Jung and Joseph Campbell have helped me in my thinking here.

Written by tomtomrant

26 December 2010 at 12:13 pm